New York Sour
The New York Sour is a classic whiskey cocktail made with bourbon, fresh lemon juice, sugar syrup and a carefully floated layer of dry red wine. This colourful variation of the Whiskey Sour combines bright citrus and smooth bourbon with dark fruit notes and gentle tannins. The result is a refreshing, beautifully layered cocktail that's ready in just 5 minutes.
New York Sour Recipe
- Bourbon whiskey 60 ml
- Lemon juice 30 ml
- Cane sugar syrup 20 ml
- Dry red wine 15 ml
- Fresh lemon 1 twist
- Ice, for shaking 150 g
- Ice, for serving 100 g
HOW TO SHAKE AND LAYER A NEW YORK SOUR
- Add 60 ml bourbon, 30 ml fresh lemon juice and 20 ml cane sugar syrup to a cocktail shaker.
- Add approximately 150 g of ice and shake firmly for 10–12 seconds until thoroughly chilled.
- Fill an Old Fashioned glass with approximately 100 g of fresh ice and strain the cocktail into the glass.
- Slowly pour 15 ml dry red wine over the back of a bar spoon held just above the drink's surface to create a distinct red layer.
- Express the oils from a fresh lemon twist over the glass and use it as the garnish. Serve immediately.
WHAT MAKES A NEW YORK SOUR?
A New York Sour is a classic Whiskey Sour finished with a carefully floated layer of dry red wine. The combination of whiskey, fresh lemon and sugar syrup provides the familiar balance of sweetness, acidity and warmth, while the wine adds dark fruit aromas and gentle tannins.
The defining feature is the contrast between the golden whiskey sour and the ruby-red wine floating above it. Rather than mixing the wine into the cocktail, layering it allows the first sips to showcase the wine before gradually blending with the whiskey and citrus underneath.
A well-made New York Sour should taste balanced and refreshing, with the red wine complementing rather than overpowering the bourbon.
Your recipe, ready to save.
Download a compact recipe card and use the QR code to return to the live builder whenever you need to scale the quantities.
NEW YORK SOUR RECIPE, INGREDIENTS & TIPS
The New York Sour starts with the familiar structure of a Whiskey Sour but adds one ingredient that completely changes both its appearance and flavour: dry red wine. Bourbon provides warmth and oak, lemon brings fresh acidity and sugar syrup balances the sourness. The final red-wine float introduces dark fruit, additional aroma and a gentle tannic finish. The result should retain two visible elements: a golden whiskey sour underneath and a deep red wine layer across the top.
THE BEST INGREDIENTS FOR A NEW YORK SOUR
A good New York Sour starts with a bourbon whiskey that has enough vanilla, caramel and oak character to remain noticeable alongside the lemon and red wine. Bourbon creates a smooth, slightly sweet base, while rye whiskey is an excellent alternative if you prefer a spicier cocktail.
Use freshly squeezed lemon juice for bright acidity and a clean citrus flavour. A good cane sugar syrup balances the sharpness without introducing competing flavours.
For the signature float, choose a dry, fruit-forward red wine with moderate tannins. Malbec is an excellent option, bringing dark berry notes and enough structure to complement the bourbon. Shiraz or a softer Merlot can also work well. Avoid very sweet wines or extremely tannic styles that might overwhelm the cocktail.
Finish with a fresh lemon twist to add a bright citrus aroma that complements the wine and whiskey.
HOW TO BALANCE A NEW YORK SOUR
The key to balancing a New York Sour is preparing a well-balanced Whiskey Sour before adding the wine. Our recipe combines 60 ml bourbon, 30 ml fresh lemon juice and 20 ml cane sugar syrup to create a bright, spirit-forward base.
If the cocktail tastes too sour, add a little more sugar syrup. If it is too sweet, increase the lemon juice slightly. Remember that the red wine also contributes acidity and tannins, so the finished drink will taste different from the base alone.
Keep the red wine float to approximately 15 ml per cocktail. This is enough to create the signature colour contrast and add dark fruit character without overpowering the whiskey, lemon and sugar.
THE STORY BEHIND THE NEW YORK SOUR
Despite its name, the New York Sour appears to have originated outside New York. Historical evidence traces whiskey sours finished with a red wine float to Chicago during the 1880s, when bartenders were already adding claret to whiskey-based sour cocktails.
Over time, variations appeared under names including Continental Sour, Southern Whiskey Sour, Chicago Sour and Claret Snap. The name New York Sour eventually became the most widely recognised.
The drink's history stretches back to the late nineteenth century, and the New York Sour name was documented by the 1880s. It also appeared in the influential 1934 Mr. Boston Bartender's Guide.
Today, the New York Sour remains a popular whiskey cocktail, recognised for its striking two-tone appearance and distinctive combination of bourbon, fresh citrus and red wine.
Difford's Guide notes that the name New York Sour appears in the 1934 Mr. Boston Bartender's Guide.
HOW TO FLOAT THE RED WINE
The red wine float is what gives the New York Sour its distinctive layered appearance. Always add the wine after shaking and straining the whiskey sour, rather than mixing it with the other ingredients.
Hold a bar spoon just above the surface of the finished cocktail, with the curved back facing upwards. Slowly pour 15 ml dry red wine over the spoon, allowing it to spread gently across the surface.
Pouring slowly reduces the disturbance to the cocktail and helps the red wine form a visible layer above the golden whiskey sour. A steady hand and a spoon held close to the surface produce the best results.
If the layers begin to mix, try pouring more slowly and using a well-chilled cocktail. Some gradual mixing is normal as the drink is enjoyed.
SERVE IT PROPERLY
Serve a New York Sour in an Old Fashioned glass filled with fresh ice. The short, wide glass displays the cocktail's signature layers: a golden whiskey sour beneath a deep ruby-red wine float.
After carefully adding the wine, avoid stirring the drink so that the colour contrast remains visible. Finish with a fresh lemon twist, gently expressing the citrus oils over the glass before placing it on the rim.
Serve immediately while the cocktail is cold and the layers are clearly defined. The red wine will gradually mingle with the whiskey sour as the drink is enjoyed, introducing new flavours with each sip.
Questions about the New York Sour
What is a New York Sour?
A New York Sour is a whiskey sour finished with a layer of red wine. The classic structure combines whiskey, fresh lemon and sugar before adding wine to the surface.
What red wine should I use for a New York Sour?
Use a dry, fruit-forward red wine with enough colour to create a visible layer. Malbec works particularly well, although Bordeaux-style reds and other dry reds can also be used. Difford's specification uses claret, while other contemporary recipes simply call for red wine.
Can I use Malbec in a New York Sour?
Yes. A dry Malbec provides deep colour, dark-fruit character and enough structure for the wine float. Le Grand Noir Malbec is our choice for this recipe.
Is a New York Sour the same as a Whiskey Sour?
Not quite. The base is essentially a Whiskey Sour, but the New York Sour adds a red-wine float, changing both its appearance and flavour.
How do I make the red wine float?
After shaking and straining the sour over fresh ice, slowly pour the red wine over the back of a bar spoon just above the surface. This helps the wine spread gently across the top rather than immediately mixing into the drink.
How much do I need for a group?
Choose 6, 12, 24 or 48 cocktails and the quantities can be calculated for you. Each New York Sour uses 60 ml bourbon, 30 ml fresh lemon juice, 20 ml cane sugar syrup and 15 ml dry red wine.
Is it an IBA cocktail?
Yes. The New York Sour is officially recognised by the International Bartenders Association in its New Era Drinks category. The IBA recipe uses rye whiskey or bourbon, fresh lemon juice, simple syrup, an egg-white component and a red wine float. Drinkero's version omits the foaming ingredient for a more clearly layered presentation. See the official IBA New York Sour recipe
